Join thousands of weekly readers and receive practical marketing advice for FREE.
MarketingSherpa's Case Studies, New Research Data, How-tos, Interviews and Articles

Enter your email below to join thousands of marketers and get FREE weekly newsletters with practical Case Studies, research and training, as well as MarketingSherpa updates and promotions.


Please refer to our Privacy Policy and About Us page for contact details.

No thanks, take me to MarketingSherpa

First Name:
Last Name:
Mar 18, 2003
Case Study

High Click Rates Aren't Always Best - What DeKemper Learned by Tracking Post-Click Activity

SUMMARY: If you are a business services marketer, definitely check out this Case Study to see how a high-priced IT consultancy tested lead generation ads in email newsletters and on Web sites. Includes actual copy from the ads and data on which offer worked best.

Plus, includes details on how DeKemper created a print (not email) newsletter that sales prospects love. We have also included a PDF sample of that newsletter for you to steal ideas from.

"We had trade show burnout," says Dan DeKemper President DeKemper & Associates.

"We certainly would have a booth at industry trade shows such as COMDEX, but you don't really have a targeted audience. You get millions of people walking in looking for free stuff."

DeKemper's typical clients spend at minimum $100,000 on IT consulting services with them (and often a whole lot more). Which means, generally it is a C-level exec who makes the final hiring decision.

"It's the type of guy you reach through personal relationships, or when you're invited to propose an RFP," notes DeKemper.

Which, no matter how enthusiastically your current client base recommends you to friends, limits you to a small pool compared to the RFP requests more famous firms get. "We're typically against IBM, Accenture, KPMG. People say, 'Who the heck are you guys? We've never even heard of you.'"

DeKemper needed another way to generate highly qualified new sales leads. Although he did not dump trade shows entirely, for 2002 he decided to test putting 20% of his regular marketing budget into buying ads in email newsletters and Web sites.


"I have an innate insecurity about advertising," says DeKemper. "I know there is branding, yeah, yeah, yeah. At the bottom line I want to see sales. I want to see results. Clicks are not working for me unless I see some sales or some prospective customer visits scheduled."

Prior to launching an online marketing campaign, first DeKemper had his in-house Web team set up a system whereby they could track all resulting clicks to see what they did once they got to his site.

In addition, his team developed reports that would quickly reveal the quality of leads registering for offers at his campaign landing pages. He was not just tracking how many leads he got, but how many were qualified, and ultimately how many turned into clients.

Next DeKemper tested three different offers that appeared on banners and/or email newsletter ads at TechTarget's and

Offer #1: White paper

Media sales reps told DeKemper that white paper offers usually got the highest click rates, so he tested one.

Sample creative:
Free SAP CRM 3.0 Whitepaper and survey results from DeKemper & Associates

Evaluating or implementing SAP CRM 3.0? Should you use CRM billing? What about your complex pricing? Configurable materials? Our R/3 and CRM certified consultants have compiled a white paper for those companies who are evaluating using mySAP CRM 3.0. We’ll ask you to fill out a quick anonymous survey we’re conducting on mySAP CRM for our clients. We promise your individual responses will remain confidential. And we WON’T ‘call’ on you unless you’d like to talk with us.

Offer #2: Trial "QuickStart" offer

Prospects always want to be able to see how their data will look using a new software system before they bite the bullet to invest in it. DeKemper offered them a two-week trial for a flat fee of 10% or less of what they would expect to pay for the final project to see their own data demoed using the new system.

"I was completely arrogant," he recalls, "I told everyone, we're going to be overwhelmed with takers!"

Sample creative:

Has your BW data warehouse project lost momentum? Are you a new SAP BW customer and need help establishing scope? DeKemper & Associates announces a special offer on SAP BW QuickStart Projects - which includes all the necessary configuration and end user reports for a complete working prototype to demo to your executives. You'll even receive a custom web based e-learning course to post on your company intranet to jumpstart your end user training - all for a fixed price and duration starting at $18,000 and 3 weeks.

Offer #3: IT staff training

The problem with buying new software systems is the high costs of continually hiring consultants to run the darn thing. DeKemper decided to offer "knowledge transfer engagements" whereby his team would train the client's in-house techs to run the system completely as it was being implemented.

"At the end of the day you're not relying on us, the whole goal was to get rid of us," he explains.

Sample creative:
Decrease your reliance on consultants through knowledge transfer

Are you investing in your SAP consultants rather than your own staff? Do you end an engagement with a firm and wonder how you'll fill the skill vacuum? DeKemper & Associates offers fixed fee and variable engagements guaranteed to train your own IT staff in the technology as you implement. We work with the latest SAP products - including R3, CRM, Business Warehouse, SEM, SCM and Portal products and can structure an implementation that meets your company's IT cost objectives and organizational goals.

At the same time as he launched the new online campaign, DeKemper also had his marketing team develop and launch a new newsletter for prospects.

"You do an ad, you get a lead, but as you start to qualify leads you find some are not ready to do anything more for three-four months. Well that's perfect for the newsletter," DeKemper explains. "We can be continually in their face for those three months."

However, instead of launching an email newsletter, he launched in print. "Most of our target audience gets barraged with email."

The newsletter was mailed as a folded self-mailer (i.e. not enclosed in an envelope. Link to sample below) and had three unusual features:

Feature #1: Lots of content
Each print issue is eight pages long with three columns of fairly small 8-point type per page. That is a heck of a lot more content than most email or print newsletters include.

Feature #2: Links to yet more content online
Many of the most interesting articles end with notes telling readers they should go to DeKemper's "members only" Web site area to get more data on the topic. Each newsletter subscriber has a personal password allowing them access to this site section.

Why not post it publicly instead?

Dan DeKemper says this allows his sales reps to know who is deeply interested in the information (and hence perhaps a better prospect), and it lets the prospects feel like they are getting access to something more valuable than content that is available at no-cost on open sites.

Exclusivity breeds value.

Feature #3: Not everything is serious
While many of the newsletter articles are professionally useful (i.e. "4 Trends that are changing the face of Enterprise Resource Planning"), some are not related to work.

For example, the Feb 2003 issue featured a lighthearted item on Hoboken NJ's lame approach to snow removal, and reviews of the best places to eat in Rome, Italy.

The lighter articles still have a tie-in with DeKemper, the firm is headquartered in Hoboken and his staff contributed the reviews.

None of the content is salesly. None talks about DeKemper's new accounts or partnerships or pushes special offers. If it is not truly useful, interesting or fun for readers, it is not included.


Dan DeKemper says he is awfully glad he set tracking in place instead of just counting clicks because some of the ads and offers that got the highest clicks ended up being worthless, and vice versa.

The campaign as a whole was so successful that he is again dedicating 20% of his 2003 marketing budget to online, and continuing with the print newsletter.

More results:

- The white paper offer got lots of clicks, but not good ones. "We found a lot of competitors and current customers downloaded them." DeKemper does not offer white papers in initial lead gen campaigns anymore.

- The "Quick Start" offer tanked big-time. DeKemper yanked it within a week.

He is glad of the investment though because running a fast test online told him it was not a good offer so he could change the rest of his traditional marketing materials to a more popular offer.

"I got instant notification that I was off-message. That was very good for us. It helped us change messaging at trade shows."

- The "Knowledge Transfer" offer was enormously popular. "We got literally about 100 enquiries filling out the form within two days of running the ad. I was looking at click through rates of 1.5-2%." These leads were definitely qualified. So far four have turned into paying consulting gigs worth six figures each.

- While ComputerWorld ads generated lots of clicks, many of them turned out to be less qualified. DeKemper moved more of his media buying budget to which was more targeted to his specific niche.

- Even then, DeKemper's team discovered that many of the clicks were actually from job seekers rather than prospects. "We saw a lot of people were coming in and going to our job board."

He took advantage of that by running banners and email newsletter ads instead of standard recruiting classifieds when he needed more staff. "It beats," says DeKemper.

- Over 2002 it became apparent that the email newsletter ads were performing significantly better than site banner ads. DeKemper has started to "thin out banners" in favor of newsletter ads.

- Feedback on the print newsletter has been highly positive. "Now people come up to us at shows and say, 'I get your newsletter every month and I love it,'" DeKemper says. "It's so cheap to get your face out there. Just $.85 per piece."

The most popular, and remembered, articles are the lighthearted ones.

Useful links:

Sample of print newsletter:


Software that DeKemper uses to track his Web visitor activity:
See Also:

Post a Comment

Note: Comments are lightly moderated. We post all comments without editing as long as they
(a) relate to the topic at hand,
(b) do not contain offensive content, and
(c) are not overt sales pitches for your company's own products/services.

To help us prevent spam, please type the numbers
(including dashes) you see in the image below.*

Invalid entry - please re-enter

*Please Note: Your comment will not appear immediately --
article comments are approved by a moderator.

Improve Your Marketing

Join our thousands of weekly Case Study readers.

Enter your email below to receive MarketingSherpa news, updates, and promotions:

Note: Already a subscriber? Want to add a subscription?
Click Here to Manage Subscriptions

Best of the Week:
Marketing case studies and research

Chart Of The Week

B2B Marketing

Consumer Marketing

Email marketing

Inbound Marketing

SherpaStore Alerts


We value your privacy and will not rent or sell your email address. Visit our About Us page for contact details.